This might even override considerations of race, as the black cultural theorist Frantz Fanon noted in his book Peau noire, masques blancspublished as Black Skin, White Masks in Commonality of speech creates a web of connections that hold a people together.
But any honest appraisal of the situation in the US must concede that it simply is not. I have lived this issue, and it is incomprehensible to me that anyone would oppose legislation which codifies the language policy for this country.
A resolution to thatthere should only be on language allowed. Lewis said instead of trying to offer diversity or multiculturalism to teach minorities to speak Standard English, the main reason being in order to get a good paying career you must be able to present yourself in.
If imposition is to be avoided as a rule, then federal speech codes must surely qualify. The American society offers a unique plight of its development aspects, especially with reference to the language issue. We wear the masks we think other people want to see While Ebonics might be a perfectly intelligible form of English to those who speak it, it goes against the grain of a white-dominated society in which belonging means talking the talk of Standard English.
To the extent that America has a national culture, it has been shaped by elements that immigrants brought with them.
They are unable to communicate with mainstream America. If the English language were under threat, matters might be different. Some agree with this and some do not, others say this is America and it is founded on diversity and freedom, which includes legal immigrants the freedom to choose weather or not to learn our language, along with many other choices you have as an American citizen.
In the essay, Should English Be the Law? They further argued that, since Ebonics was structured and spoken like any other language, its place in school texts was no more or less arbitrary than Standard English or Spanish.
This means that English should not be made a law. You can keep in touch with your writer, check the draft of your paper and send your order for revision for free. It had never been an issue before and it is not an issue now. He is a regular contributor at the Religion Dispatches blog. Instead of making life easier for new immigrants — assuming this is a goal — such a law would likely just bar them from even more opportunities.
The American society should be different and people should have the freedom of choice.
If individuals do not learn to speak a common language, for instance, English, there will be a possibility that there will be the development of cultural enclaves, as opposed to assimilation. In my opinion, I think that everyone in America should learn English and have English as our native tongue, and rule out other languages for primary use.
Such thinking feeds directly into a more basic question of US identity: It would be false to think that there is no price to be paid for those migrants who cannot communicate in English. Likewise, since non-speakers would be further stigmatised, their nativist detractors could claim legal vindication for every exclusionary push.
Even in southern states, a white police officer is more likely to identify with a black driver who speaks regional English in an accent they share, than with one speaking the widely stereotyped urban style. If the issue regarding language is not addressed, there is the likelihood of different problems culminating into the fall of the American society.
This will go a long way in ensuring that certain vices associated with diverse languages are avoided.
Their communication with American citizens would also be jeopardized. The English spoken in Georgia, for instance, is very different from that spoken in Massachusetts. Dismissing the idea that language was a threat to unity, he concluded: He believes there should not be an option not to learn English if you live in America.
These days, the numbers are similar. Furthermore, there has always been and will always be a problem with America being a melting pot of different languages. Place an orderadd your paper details and enjoy the results! Ebonics was deeply entangled with white perceptions of black otherness, relating to race, class, morality and violence, thus draping it with an added layer of threat.
So here is the question, should there be one language used in America? The troublesome example of official French policy in Quebec offers a cautionary tale One promising avenue for integrating non-speakers comes in the form of bilingual immersion education.
Speaking English, they might argue, does not guarantee humanity in the eyes of individuals or — perhaps more importantly — systems.
One prerequisite of being an American, as we have seen, is the ability to speak English. The question however is too simplistic: There are people from European countries, South American countries, Asian countries, and many more.
Therefore, instead of assimilating them, such language policy will isolate them. King, in his work, Should English Be the Law?Here are a couple of opinions shared by Robert D. King, "Should English be the Law?", S.I. Hayakawa, "Bilingualism in America: English Should be the Official Language", and Greg Lewis " An Open Letter to Diversity's Victims".
Should English Be the Law? Robert D. King. April Issue. Never in the heyday of rule by sovereign was it a condition of employment that the King be able to speak the language of his. King, Robert D. “Should English Be the Law?” The Presence of Others.
Comp. Andrea A. Lunsford and John J. Ruszkiewicz. English Language Communication Essays] Strong Essays words ( pages) English Should be the National Language Essay examples Should English be America's national language?] Strong Essays words ( Should English Be The Law By Robert D King Mr.
Schulze 1 English Synthesis Essay This is a synthesis essay on the English only debate. In the essay, Should English Be the Law?, by Robert D. King, he states that "The US House of Representatives approved a bill that would make English the official language of the United States. The vote was in favor.".
In “Should English Be the Law?”, Robert King discusses the debate over if English should be made the official language of the United States by law.Download